The choice between an air and a magnetic rowing machine mostly comes down to two questions: do you want resistance that grows with your effort, and how much noise can your home handle? Both styles give a full-body workout that works your legs, back, core and arms, but they feel very different once you start pulling.
In this guide we explain how each resistance system works, where each one wins, and which models on Amazon are worth buying. All prices and ratings were checked on Amazon in October 2026. For a deeper look at fan-based machines, see our air rowing machines review.
Quick Picks: Air vs Magnetic
- Air flywheel with damper 1 to 10
- PM5 performance monitor
- About 96″L x 24″W, ~500 lb max user
- Splits in two for storage
Sunny Health & Fitness Smart Magnetic Rower
- Magnetic, 16 levels
- 300 lb max user weight
- 64″L x 19.3″W x 27″H, 41 lb
- 45.7″ rail, SunnyFit app
- Magnetic, 16 levels
- 350 lb max user weight
- 65″L x 19.3″W x 24.8″H, 42 lb
- Dual slide rail
Air and Magnetic Rowers Compared
| Rower | Best For | Key Specs | Amazon Rating | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Concept2 RowErg | Best Air Rower Overall | Air flywheel with damper 1 to 10; PM5 performance monitor; About 96″L x 24″W, ~500 lb max user | 4.9/5 | Check Price |
| 2. Sunny Health & Fitness Smart Magnetic Rower | Best Magnetic Rower for Most People | Magnetic, 16 levels; 300 lb max user weight; 64″L x 19.3″W x 27″H, 41 lb | 4.4/5 | Check Price |
| 3. Merach Q1S Magnetic Rower | Quietest Budget Magnetic Rower | Magnetic, 16 levels; 350 lb max user weight; 65″L x 19.3″W x 24.8″H, 42 lb | 4.4/5 | Check Price |
| 4. YOSUDA H-185 Magnetic Rower | Best Magnetic Rower for Stability | Magnetic, 16 levels; 350 lb max user weight; 64.57″L x 17.72″W x 28.35″H, 54 lb | 4.5/5 | Check Price |
| 5. GMWD Lava Flow Air Rower | Best Budget Air Rower | Air with 10-level damper; 500 lb max user weight; 95″L x 24″W x 14″H, 72 lb | 4.2/5 | Check Price |
| 6. Sunny Health & Fitness Smart Magnetic Rowing Machine (SF-RW523021) | Best Premium Magnetic Rower for Tall Users | Magnetic resistance; About 300 lb (135 kg) max user; 79.3″L x 19.7″W x 36.4″H, 68 lb | 4.5/5 | Check Price |
1. Concept2 RowErg – Best Air Rower Overall
- Air flywheel with damper 1 to 10
- PM5 performance monitor
- About 96″L x 24″W, ~500 lb max user
- Splits in two for storage
Pros
- ✓ The standard erg for racing, CrossFit and online rankings
- ✓ 4.9 stars on 13,000+ ratings
- ✓ PM5 data is consistent across machines
Cons
- ✗ About $990
- ✗ Needs roughly 9 x 4 ft of floor
- ✗ Louder than magnetic rowers
The RowErg is the benchmark the whole air-versus-magnetic debate is measured against. Its flywheel spins inside a housing with a damper you set from 1 to 10, but the real resistance comes from how hard you pull: a stronger drive moves more air and the machine pushes back. That is why the same erg works for a 60-year-old beginner and an Olympic rower.
The PM5 monitor gives pace per 500 m, watts and calories that match every other Concept2 in the world, so a 2K time on your RowErg means the same thing in a CrossFit box. The trade-offs are price, a long 8-foot footprint and a steady whoosh that you will hear in the next room.
Best for: Athletes, CrossFitters and anyone who wants comparable, race-standard numbers.
May not fit: Apartment dwellers who row early in the morning or anyone with less than 9 feet of floor.
2. Sunny Health & Fitness Smart Magnetic Rower – Best Magnetic Rower for Most People
- Magnetic, 16 levels
- 300 lb max user weight
- 64″L x 19.3″W x 27″H, 41 lb
- 45.7″ rail, SunnyFit app
Pros
- ✓ 19,000+ ratings, the most here
- ✓ About $199
- ✓ SunnyFit app classes
Cons
- ✗ 300 lb limit
- ✗ 45.7-inch rail is short for tall rowers
- ✗ Resistance feels capped for athletes
Sunny’s Smart Magnetic Rower is the easiest way to see why magnetic rowers sell so well. With more than 19,000 Amazon ratings at 4.4 stars, it is the most-reviewed rower we track. A magnet moves closer to a metal flywheel as you turn the 16-level knob, so resistance stays the same no matter how fast you pull.
That fixed resistance is great for steady cardio while watching TV, and the machine is quiet enough that the loudest sound is the seat rolling. Its 45.7-inch rail is the limitation: riders over about 6 feet may run out of slide at full extension.
Best for: Beginners and casual rowers who value quiet and low cost.
May not fit: Tall rowers or anyone chasing hard sprint intervals.
3. Merach Q1S Magnetic Rower – Quietest Budget Magnetic Rower
- Magnetic, 16 levels
- 350 lb max user weight
- 65″L x 19.3″W x 24.8″H, 42 lb
- Dual slide rail
Pros
- ✓ Very quiet magnetic brake
- ✓ 2,300+ ratings at 4.4
- ✓ About $190
Cons
- ✗ Resistance tops out early for strong rowers
- ✗ Short rail for riders over about 6’2″
- ✗ No watt readout on the basic monitor
The Merach Q1S uses a dual slide rail and a magnetic brake that runs almost silently, which makes it a favorite with people in apartments. At about $190 with 2,300+ ratings, it shows how cheap a solid magnetic rower can be.
Its 16 levels feel fine for most cardio sessions, but strong rowers report that the top setting arrives quickly. Unlike an air rower, pulling harder does not add more load, so sprint pieces feel flatter.
Best for: Shared walls, late-night workouts and tight budgets.
May not fit: Strong rowers who want resistance that keeps scaling with effort.
4. YOSUDA H-185 Magnetic Rower – Best Magnetic Rower for Stability
- Magnetic, 16 levels
- 350 lb max user weight
- 64.57″L x 17.72″W x 28.35″H, 54 lb
- Bluetooth app
Pros
- ✓ 4.5 stars on 2,500+ ratings
- ✓ Heavier 54 lb frame feels steadier
- ✓ Narrow 17.7-inch width
Cons
- ✗ About $260
- ✗ Not as smooth at high stroke rates as air
- ✗ Monitor lacks watts
YOSUDA’s H-185 weighs 54 lb, noticeably more than most magnetic rowers in its price band, and that extra mass helps it stay put during longer sessions. It holds 4.5 stars on more than 2,500 ratings.
It is narrow at 17.7 inches and runs quietly, but like all magnetic machines its monitor shows time, distance and strokes rather than watts, so it is less useful if you want to compare your numbers to a Concept2.
Best for: Home users who want a sturdier magnetic rower without paying air-rower prices.
May not fit: Anyone who wants watts-based training data.
5. GMWD Lava Flow Air Rower – Best Budget Air Rower
- Air with 10-level damper
- 500 lb max user weight
- 95″L x 24″W x 14″H, 72 lb
- Foldable, device holder
Pros
- ✓ 500 lb rating at under $400
- ✓ Concept2-style layout and damper
- ✓ Folds for storage
Cons
- ✗ About 66 ratings
- ✗ Monitor is basic
- ✗ Long 95-inch footprint
If you like the way an air rower scales with effort but cannot justify Concept2 money, the GMWD Lava Flow copies the layout: long rail, fan housing at the front and a 10-level damper. It is rated for an unusually high 500 lb and folds for storage.
It has only about 66 ratings so far and a basic monitor, so treat it as a value pick rather than a race tool. It is still louder than any magnetic rower, which is the main trade-off of air resistance.
Best for: Users who want air resistance feel on a budget, including heavier rowers.
May not fit: People who need comparable PM5-style data or a quiet machine.
6. Sunny Health & Fitness Smart Magnetic Rowing Machine (SF-RW523021) – Best Premium Magnetic Rower for Tall Users
- Magnetic resistance
- About 300 lb (135 kg) max user
- 79.3″L x 19.7″W x 36.4″H, 68 lb
- Smart app, transport wheels
Pros
- ✓ Long 79-inch frame suits taller rowers
- ✓ 4.5 stars on 4,900+ ratings
- ✓ Quiet enough for apartments
Cons
- ✗ About $400
- ✗ Longer footprint than budget magnetic rowers
- ✗ Still not a true race-standard erg
This larger Sunny model stretches to 79.3 inches, so taller rowers get a full stroke without hitting the end of the rail. It holds 4.5 stars on roughly 4,900 ratings and stays quiet enough for shared spaces.
At about $400 it costs twice as much as compact magnetic rowers. It still will not give you the variable, effort-matched resistance of an air rower, but it is one of the most comfortable magnetic options for longer steady sessions.
Best for: Taller users who prefer quiet magnetic resistance.
May not fit: Small rooms or buyers who just need a basic rower.
Air vs Magnetic Rowing Machine: Key Differences
How the resistance works
An air rower uses a fan flywheel. The harder and faster you pull, the more air it moves and the more it resists, so resistance scales with effort automatically. A magnetic rower moves a magnet closer to or farther from a flywheel; you pick a level and the load stays roughly fixed regardless of how hard you pull.
Stroke feel
Air rowers feel closer to rowing on water: a strong catch, then a smooth fade through the finish. Magnetic rowers feel even and predictable but can feel flat when you try to sprint, because pulling harder does not add more load.
Noise
Magnetic rowers are close to silent, which matters in apartments and shared homes. Air rowers produce a whooshing fan noise that rises with your effort; it is not loud enough to bother most households, but you will not row quietly at 5 a.m.
Price and durability
Good magnetic rowers start around $190 to $260, while the benchmark air rower costs about $990. Magnetic brakes have few wearing parts. Air rowers are also simple and very durable, which is why gyms use them for years.
Space
Most budget magnetic rowers are 58 to 65 inches long and fold or stand up. Full-size air rowers like the Concept2 run about 8 feet and need roughly 9 x 4 ft of floor, though they split in two for storage.
Training goals
If you want comparable numbers for CrossFit, racing or online rankings, air is the clear choice. If you want steady, quiet cardio and a lower price, magnetic is easier to live with. Many people who train hard on an air bike also prefer air on the rower; see our best air bikes guide for that side of the gym.
FAQ
Is an air or magnetic rowing machine better for beginners?
Both work. Magnetic rowers are cheaper and quieter, and the fixed levels make it easy to start slow. Air rowers are just as beginner-friendly because resistance is light when you pull gently; they cost more and are louder.
Are air rowers louder than magnetic rowers?
Yes. Air rowers make a fan noise that grows with effort. Magnetic rowers are nearly silent apart from the seat rolling on the rail.
Which rowing machine burns more calories?
Calorie burn depends on effort, not the brake type. Air rowers make it easier to push harder in sprints because resistance rises with you, so high-intensity sessions tend to feel more demanding.
Do CrossFit gyms use air or magnetic rowers?
CrossFit boxes almost always use air rowers, usually the Concept2 RowErg, because the numbers are standardized for workouts and competitions.
How long do magnetic rowers last?
A quality magnetic rower can last many years because the magnetic brake has no friction contact. The seat rollers and strap are the usual wear items.
Final Verdict
If you want the most effective and future-proof rower and have the space, the Concept2 RowErg is the safest choice in the air-versus-magnetic debate. For quiet, budget-friendly cardio, the Sunny Smart Magnetic Rower and Merach Q1S deliver smooth, near-silent sessions for under $200.
Pick air if you train hard and care about data; pick magnetic if you care about noise, space and price. Either way, you will get a low-impact, full-body workout.
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!